Measurement

How GA4 and Google Ads attribution models decide which channel gets credit

GA4 and Google Ads both credit conversions to channels, but with different models, lookback windows and defaults. Here is how each one works and which settings to check first.

A conversion has to be credited to something. The model that does the crediting sets how much each channel appears to earn, and that figure feeds bidding.

Google Analytics 4 and Google Ads each apply their own model and their own time window.

Which attribution models GA4 still offers

GA4 supports three reporting models: data-driven attribution, paid and organic last click, and Google paid channels last click. According to Google's Analytics documentation, the first click, linear, time decay and position-based models stopped being available in November 2023.

All of the current models leave out direct visits. A direct visit gets credit only when the entire path to the key event was direct.

Paid and organic last click gives 100% of the credit to the last channel the user clicked, or engaged with in the case of YouTube views. Google paid channels last click gives 100% to the last Google Ads channel in the path. If the path has no Google Ads click, it falls back to paid and organic last click.

An engaged view counts when a user watches an ad for 30 seconds, or to the end if the ad is shorter.

How data-driven attribution splits credit

Data-driven attribution uses machine learning on both converting and non-converting paths. Google lists the inputs as time from the key event, device type, number of ad interactions, order of exposure and creative asset type.

The model compares what happened with what could have occurred without a given touchpoint. Credit follows how much each ad interaction changes the estimated probability of a key event.

Google's own example: if the probability of a key event is 3% and falls to 2% without one exposure, that exposure accounts for a 50% lift. Depending on data availability, it may also draw on aggregate data from data-sharing settings.

Conversions can be reattributed for up to 7 days after they happen, so figures for recent conversions can change.

The model distributes credit for key events that have already happened.

Lookback windows in GA4

The lookback window sets how far back from a key event GA4 searches for touchpoints that can earn credit. Google's attribution settings page gives two defaults.

Acquisition key events, which are first_open and first_visit, default to 30 days and can be switched to 7 days. All other key events default to 90 days and can be set to 30 or 60 days.

The window applies to every attribution model and key event type. It also applies to session attribution.

Google's example shows the mechanism. With a 30-day window, a key event on January 30 can be attributed only to touchpoints from January 1 to 30. A touchpoint on December 20 falls outside a 30-day window and cannot receive credit.

The settings sit under Admin, then Events, then Attribution settings. They require the Marketer role or higher at the property level. The three settings there are the reporting attribution model, the channels eligible for credit and the key event lookback window.

What Google Ads counts differently

Google Ads lists two models: last click and data-driven. Data-driven attribution distributes credit using an account's past data for each conversion action, and it is the default for most conversion actions.

First click, linear, time decay and position-based models are no longer supported in Google Ads. Conversion actions that used them were upgraded to data-driven attribution.

Google Ads measures time from the ad interaction. A conversion counts for an interaction if it is recorded within the conversion window that follows it.

The click-through window defaults to 30 days. For Search and Display it can be set from 1 day up to 30, 60 or 90 days, depending on the conversion source.

The engaged-view window for video defaults to 3 days and can be set from 1 to 30 days. The view-through window defaults to 1 day and can be set from 1 to 30 days or 1 to 4 weeks.

Google recommends windows of at least 7 days so that conversion data is richer. Smart Bidding strategies such as Target CPA and Target ROAS count and optimize conversions over whichever window is chosen.

A touchpoint on December 20 falls outside a 30-day window and cannot receive credit.

How the two tools' defaults compare

The defaults differ. For key events other than first_open and first_visit, GA4 searches 90 days back, while Google Ads defaults to a 30-day click-through window and a 1-day view-through window.

The channels in scope differ too. A Google paid channels last click model in GA4 credits the last Google Ads channel clicked, and falls back to paid and organic last click when the path has no Google Ads click. GA4's other last-click model can credit organic search or email instead.

Direct visits are excluded from credit in GA4 models, unless the whole path was direct. Google Ads measures the conversion window from the ad interaction.

Google says Google Analytics will help identify and reconcile discrepancies between Google Analytics and Google Ads conversion settings.

What changes retroactively and what does not

The rules on changing settings differ, and they matter when comparing periods. In GA4, changing the reporting attribution model applies to both historical and future data. A report for last quarter will show new numbers after the switch.

Changing the GA4 lookback window applies going forward only. The same holds in Google Ads: changing a conversion window is not retroactive, and conversions that fall outside a window after it is shortened are not counted retroactively.

GA4 also has limits on how far back each model reaches. Attribution models were introduced on different dates: data-driven attribution for paid and organic channels on November 1, 2021, and the rules-based models on June 14, 2021. Date ranges that start before a model's start date show partial data.

The order of checks that follows from these rules is short. Confirm the reporting model in GA4 attribution settings, then the lookback window for non-acquisition key events. Next, confirm the click-through and view-through windows on each Google Ads conversion action, and note the date of any change before comparing periods.

Sources

  1. About attribution and attribution modeling (Analytics Help) — Google
  2. Attribution settings (Analytics Help) — Google
  3. About attribution models (Google Ads Help) — Google
  4. About conversion windows (Google Ads Help) — Google

More from Insights